2025 NFL's Most Underpaid Players: Impact on Player Prop Bets and Futures

As the 2025 NFL free agency frenzy winds down, it’s the perfect time to analyze not only the offseason's blockbuster deals—but also the bargains. Some of the league's brightest stars are still playing on rookie contracts or below-market deals, making them ideal targets for player prop bets and long-term fantasy and futures value.

Here's a full team-by-team breakdown of the most underpaid player on each roster, and how their roles could influence the best NFL prop bets and the best player props today this season:

AFC East

Buffalo Bills – RB James Cook
Cook has produced 2,800+ scrimmage yards and 24 touchdowns over the last two seasons while on a rookie deal. His reliability and usage make him one of the best player props today for rushing and receiving yards.

Miami Dolphins – RB De’Von Achane
Explosive, versatile, and affordable. Achane totaled nearly 1,500 yards in 2024 and is a sneaky favorite in player prop bets for anytime TDs and yards from scrimmage.

New England Patriots – CB Christian Gonzalez
Already an All-Pro at 22, Gonzalez is becoming a lock in best NFL prop bets involving passes defended and INTs.

New York Jets – WR Garrett Wilson
Three straight 1,000-yard seasons and a steady red-zone threat—his receptions and TDs are best player props today value bets every week.

AFC North

Baltimore Ravens – C Tyler Linderbaum
The engine of Baltimore’s offensive line. His consistency boosts the offense, making Ravens skill players like Lamar Jackson and Keaton Mitchell high-value prop bets.

Cincinnati Bengals – RB Chase Brown
Breakout alert. Over 1,300 scrimmage yards in 2024, and with Mixon gone, Brown’s rushing overs are must-watch player prop bets.

Cleveland Browns – LB Mohamoud Diabate
Undrafted and already making plays. A low-cost starter with tackle props worth tracking.

Pittsburgh Steelers – WR George Pickens
Pickens is underpaid and underrated. With or without Metcalf, his overs in receiving yards remain best NFL prop bets week to week.

AFC South

Houston Texans – LB Henry To’oTo’o
Over 100 tackles last year and only getting better. An IDP gem and solid for defensive player prop bets.

Indianapolis Colts – WR Josh Downs
His chemistry with Anthony Richardson is growing. Expect value on receptions and receiving yards every week.

Jacksonville Jaguars – WR Brian Thomas Jr.
A Pro Bowl rookie with 1,200+ yards and 10 TDs. Lock him in for player prop bets involving deep ball touchdowns.

Tennessee Titans – DT T’Vondre Sweat
Already dominant up front. Don’t sleep on sack or tackle-for-loss props when available.

AFC West

Denver Broncos – QB Bo Nix
Efficient and quickly becoming elite. His passing yards and completions are among the best player props today.

Kansas City Chiefs – CB Trent McDuffie
All-Pro lockdown corner. Bet the under on opposing WR props when McDuffie’s on assignment.

Las Vegas Raiders – TE Brock Bowers
A rookie with All-Pro status? That’s rare. Bowers is instant value in receptions, TDs, and yards props.

Los Angeles Chargers – WR Ladd McConkey
Seven TDs and 1,100+ yards as a rookie. He’s a new go-to target and a great player prop bet at low market pricing.

NFC East

Dallas Cowboys – G Tyler Smith
His protection helps Prescott and Pollard deliver consistent fantasy and prop success.

New York Giants – LB Micah McFadden
Two straight 100-tackle seasons. Look out for tackles and assisted tackles player prop bets.

Philadelphia Eagles – LB Nakobe Dean
128 tackles in 2024. A silent force with strong value in defensive overs—watch his return post-injury.

Washington Commanders – QB Jayden Daniels
Rookie of the Year, but still cheap. Rushing yards, total TDs, and fantasy points props are gold.

NFC North

Chicago Bears – DT Gervon Dexter
Emerging pass-rusher with upside. Sack props could be undervalued for a few more weeks.

Detroit Lions – S Kerby Joseph
All-Pro safety with nine INTs last season. INT and pass breakup props are big-value NFL prop bets.

Green Bay Packers – OT Zach Tom
A cornerstone in the trenches. His presence ensures consistent QB and RB production—watch Packers offensive props.

Minnesota Vikings – EDGE Andrew Van Ginkel
Second-team All-Pro and underrated. Sack props are currently low-priced and primed to hit.

NFC South

Atlanta Falcons – WR Drake London
Nine TDs last season. He’s heating up and could become one of the best player props today for receptions and scores.

Carolina Panthers – OT Ikem Ekwonu
Solid blindside protector. With Bryce Young developing, Ekwonu’s role helps stabilize offensive prop bets.

New Orleans Saints – OT Taliese Fuaga
Promising young tackle. Not a direct prop target, but boosts value of RB and QB props.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers – RB Bucky Irving
1,500+ scrimmage yards as a rookie—top tier in rushing + receiving props value. One of the season’s best NFL prop bets.

NFC West

Arizona Cardinals – TE Trey McBride
Over 1,100 yards in 2024. He’s rising fast and is consistently undervalued in reception and yardage props.

Los Angeles Rams – WR Puka Nacua
One of the biggest steals in the league. Top 10 in most WR props. Bankable in player prop bets each week.

San Francisco 49ers – QB Brock Purdy
The league’s highest passer rating—and still one of the cheapest. His overs are among the best player props today.

Seattle Seahawks – WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba
100 catches last season. Watch his prop lines rise, but there’s still value in receptions and YAC.

‍

Whether you’re betting overs on rising WRs or defensive standouts, these underpaid stars offer sneaky value in the best NFL prop bets for the 2025 season. Stay ahead of the curve by backing the most efficient contracts in football before the rest of the market catches on.

‍

‍