Who Would Benefit More from a 5th NBA Title—Stephen Curry or LeBron James?

As the 2025 NBA Playoffs approach, the spotlight is once again on two of the game’s most iconic figures: Stephen Curry and LeBron James. At 37 and 40 years old respectively, both are defying time and still playing at an elite level—firmly in the top 15-20 players in the league.

With Jimmy Butler now alongside Curry and Luka Dončić paired with LeBron, both teams look ready for a serious title push. But here's the million-dollar question: Who gains more legacy-wise from a fifth championship? Let’s break it down—and explore how this affects player prop bets, the best NBA prop bets, and the best player props today.

Stephen Curry: Cementing a Top-10 Legacy?

Dan Favale argues that Curry has more room to climb historically. While LeBron is locked into the top two conversation alongside Michael Jordan, Curry’s all-time ranking is less settled.

Is he top 10? Top 15? Top 25? Opinions vary wildly. Critics often point to Finals MVP snubs and say he wasn’t the best player on some of his championship squads (namely, during the Kevin Durant years). However, his 2022 title—and any new one in 2025—clearly showcases him as the central figure.

A fifth ring would elevate Curry from “GOAT shooter” to “GOAT contender,” potentially placing him above legends like Tim Duncan and Magic Johnson in the all-time hierarchy.

Impact on player props: If Curry leads Golden State to another title, expect a significant spike in his usage rate and scoring props. Bettors will see sharp movements in the best NBA prop bets, particularly in three-point makes and points.

LeBron James: Catching the GOAT's Ghost

Greg Swartz makes the case for LeBron. Statistically, LeBron has already passed Jordan in nearly every major metric—points, All-Star appearances, All-NBA selections—you name it.

But one thing eludes him: six rings. A fifth title would bring him within striking distance and further legitimize his GOAT case, especially for fans still clinging to MJ’s 6–0 Finals record.

LeBron’s enduring dominance at age 40 is a legacy of its own. Still, a ring in 2025—perhaps carried in part by Luka Dončić—could be the final stamp of greatness.

Impact on player props: If LeBron secures another championship, expect increased volatility in player prop bets. Bettors will need to assess the balance between LeBron and Luka’s contributions, influencing the best player props today for both stars.

Steph's Case for Greatness—Revisited

Zach Buckley believes there’s “no debate” here—Curry benefits more. While LeBron’s legacy is sealed, Steph is still climbing. Despite being the greatest shooter ever, he’s still left out of many top-10 GOAT lists.

With accolades like two MVPs (one unanimous), a 50/40/90 season, and four rings (two without KD), Curry has the résumé. But one more could tip the scales in his favor forever.

Betting angle: The best NBA prop bets will likely favor Curry in key postseason matchups. Another Finals MVP would skyrocket his value in player prop bets, especially for those riding the over on Steph’s scoring totals.

Five Rings: Would It Even Change LeBron’s Narrative?

Andy Bailey points out that MJ loyalists won’t budge. Even with five titles, many will still cite Jordan’s perfect Finals record. LeBron's already locked into the MJ-vs-LeBron GOAT debate, and a fifth ring—while historic—won’t necessarily tip the scales.

Meanwhile, Curry’s resume gains real weight. A third post-KD title would support the claim that he was the real driver of the Warriors dynasty, not just a sidekick to Durant.

Player props trend: With LeBron’s legacy mostly unaffected, expect Dončić to emerge as the more valuable asset in best player props today—especially if narratives shift toward “Luka’s first title.”

The Verdict: Who Gains More?

All five NBA experts from Bleacher Report agree: Stephen Curry benefits more from a fifth title.

Eric Pincus argues that another championship would elevate Curry beyond just being the game’s most lethal shooter. He’d enter the conversation alongside the likes of Kobe, Magic, and Duncan—players with five rings who are still ranked above him in many lists.

Grant Hughes adds that Curry has more legacy “real estate” to gain. While LeBron’s fifth might be remembered more as Luka’s first, Steph’s would definitively be his own.

Betting Implications for 2025

So what does this all mean for the betting markets?

• For Curry: Expect increasing betting value on overs for points, threes, and usage as he looks to carry the Warriors through another playoff run.
• For LeBron: Props may fluctuate based on Dončić’s output, with rebounding, assists, and clutch-time performance being the key categories.
• For both: Their legacy battles elevate every game’s stakes—making their player prop bets essential viewing for fans and bettors alike.

If you’re searching for the best player props today, following Curry and LeBron’s title push might be the sharpest play on the board.

Conclusion:

Stephen Curry has more to gain. Another ring would redefine his place in NBA history and reshape the best NBA prop bets market. While LeBron’s legacy is already carved in stone, Steph’s story is still being written—and another chapter could change everything.

Stay tuned for more postseason breakdowns and daily updates on the top player prop bets.

‍