` ` ` `

The Fatal Flaw: Why Each NFL Playoff Contender Could Fall Short in 2024-25

December 18, 2024

As the NFL playoffs loom, every postseason-bound team carries with it hopes of lifting the Lombardi Trophy. But no team is without weaknesses. Whether it’s inconsistency, injuries, or shaky coaching, even the strongest contenders have a fatal flaw that could send them packing before the confetti falls.

Below, we break down why each team in the playoff hunt faces challenges that bettors and fans alike should watch closely when placing player prop bets or analyzing the best NFL prop bets.

AFC East

Buffalo Bills: Defense Can’t Hold

Buffalo’s offense remains explosive, but the defense has unraveled at critical moments. Allowing over 30 points in back-to-back weeks has exposed their inability to close out games, even against mediocre opponents. For those eyeing best player props today, opposing quarterbacks and wide receivers could continue thriving against this faltering secondary.

AFC North

Baltimore Ravens: No Lockdown Secondary

The Ravens have the tools to dominate, but their secondary remains unreliable. Giving up big plays in the passing game has been their undoing against top-tier opponents. In playoff matchups where precision counts, Baltimore risks falling behind early.

Pittsburgh Steelers: Boom or Bust Offense

The Steelers’ offense has been unpredictable at best. One week they light up the scoreboard, the next they struggle to score at all. Their reliance on splash plays without consistency makes them a risky bet for deep playoff success.

AFC South

Houston Texans: C.J. Stroud Needs More Time

C.J. Stroud has been impressive in his sophomore year, but he’s working behind a struggling offensive line. The protection issues have led to erratic performances, and in a playoff setting, it’s hard to see Stroud thriving under constant pressure. Look for player prop bets targeting Houston’s sack totals as defenses exploit their weaknesses.

AFC West

Denver Broncos: Bo Nix’s Growing Pains

The Broncos have surprised many, but relying on a rookie quarterback like Bo Nix to navigate playoff pressure is a tall order. His five interceptions this month remind us why no rookie has ever won a Super Bowl as a starter.

Kansas City Chiefs: Mahomes Can’t Do It Alone

Patrick Mahomes has kept Kansas City afloat, but the supporting cast has failed him. With an inconsistent receiving corps and lackluster rushing attack, the Chiefs’ offense simply isn’t the juggernaut we’re used to seeing.

NFC East

Philadelphia Eagles: The Passing Problem

The Eagles are elite in the trenches, but their passing game has lacked rhythm this season. Jalen Hurts and his receivers must rediscover their chemistry to contend with the NFL’s best defenses. Without it, Philadelphia’s road to glory looks shaky.

Washington Commanders: Too Much on Daniels

Jayden Daniels has injected life into Washington, but putting playoff pressure on a rookie quarterback is risky. His struggles against blitz-heavy defenses could be exploited when it matters most.

NFC North

Detroit Lions: A Wounded Defense

The Lions’ dream season has hit a roadblock: injuries. The defense, once a cornerstone of their success, has been decimated. Against high-powered playoff offenses, Detroit might not have enough depth to survive.

Green Bay Packers: Unfamiliar Territory

The Packers have surprised many with their success, but this young team hasn’t faced true adversity yet. Navigating a brutal playoff path, potentially all on the road, is a tall order for a team still learning how to win.

NFC South

Atlanta Falcons: The Rookie Hurdle

Michael Penix Jr.’s debut has been exciting, but history is not on his side. No rookie quarterback has ever led their team to a Super Bowl, and Penix’s inexperience is likely to be exposed under playoff pressure.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Careless Turnovers

The Buccaneers have the talent to win, but their turnover issues remain a problem. Baker Mayfield has had flashes of brilliance but has also been prone to giveaways—an unforgivable mistake in close playoff games.

NFC West

Arizona Cardinals: The Kyler Conundrum

Kyler Murray’s inconsistency has been glaring this season. Without consistent elite play from their star quarterback, the Cardinals lack the firepower to outlast the NFL’s toughest playoff defenses.

Los Angeles Rams: Defensive Instability

The Rams’ defense is a wildcard. In some weeks, it looks impenetrable; in others, it falls apart completely. That kind of inconsistency is a liability in the high-stakes environment of the postseason.

Seattle Seahawks: Good, Not Great

The Seahawks are a solid team, but there’s nothing they do at an elite level. Their offense, defense, and special teams all hover around average. In a league where greatness is required, Seattle simply falls short.

Conclusion

The path to Super Bowl 59 is full of obstacles, and every contender carries a flaw that could end their run. Whether it’s young quarterbacks, defensive struggles, or untimely turnovers, these weaknesses will define January football. For bettors seeking the best NFL prop bets and player prop bets, identifying these cracks can offer an edge when selecting best player props today in critical matchups.

Latest Insights

See all articles →